Heinkel He 118: The Dive Bomber's Failed Bet
The Heinkel He 118 represents one of aviation history's most dramatic failures—a dive bomber design that showed initial promise but ultimately lost the competition to become the Luftwaffe's standard dive bomber to the legendary Junkers Ju 87 Stuka. The He 118's story is one of ambitious engineering, catastrophic testing accidents, and the harsh realities of aircraft development during a period of intense competition and rapid technological advancement.
Design and Development
In 1935, the German Air Ministry (RLM) issued specifications for a new dive bomber to equip the rapidly expanding Luftwaffe. Ernst Heinkel Flugzeugwerke, eager to secure this important contract, responded with the He 118—a single-engine, two-seat dive bomber designed to deliver precision attacks against ground targets.
The He 118 featured several design characteristics intended to optimize dive bombing performance:
- Low-wing monoplane configuration: All-metal stressed-skin construction for strength and aerodynamic efficiency.
- Inverted gull wing: A distinctive cranked wing design intended to provide ground clearance for the propeller while keeping the landing gear short and strong.
- Powerful engine: Daimler-Benz DB 600 inverted V-12 engine providing substantial power.
- Dive brakes: Deployable surfaces to control speed during steep diving attacks.
- Tandem cockpits: Pilot and rear gunner/radio operator in separate enclosed cockpits.
- Substantial bomb load: Internal and external provisions for bombs up to 500 kg.
The inverted gull wing was particularly distinctive, giving the He 118 a unique appearance and theoretically offering structural and aerodynamic advantages for dive bombing operations.
The Competition
The He 118 faced direct competition from several other designs, most notably the Junkers Ju 87. The RLM conducted extensive comparative trials throughout 1936-1937 to determine which aircraft would become the Luftwaffe's standard dive bomber—a decision that would affect thousands of aircraft and countless combat operations.
Initial testing showed the He 118 had certain advantages:
- Higher top speed than the Ju 87
- More powerful engine
- Sleeker, more modern appearance
- Good diving characteristics
However, the aircraft also exhibited concerning issues:
- Complex structure requiring more maintenance
- Higher production costs
- Stability concerns during certain flight regimes
- Less docile handling than the Ju 87
Catastrophic Failure
The He 118's fate was sealed by a series of catastrophic structural failures during testing. The most dramatic incident occurred when the aircraft's wings failed during a high-speed dive, resulting in the complete destruction of the prototype. Test pilot and crew were forced to bail out as the aircraft disintegrated around them—a terrifying experience that highlighted fundamental structural weaknesses in the design.
This catastrophic failure, along with other incidents revealing structural and stability issues, severely damaged confidence in the He 118. While Heinkel attempted to address these problems through redesign, the delays and the loss of confidence proved insurmountable.
The Junkers Ju 87, meanwhile, demonstrated consistent reliability and predictable handling characteristics. While slower and less elegant than the He 118, the Ju 87 proved to be a robust, stable dive bombing platform that pilots could trust—crucial qualities for an aircraft that would operate in the demanding dive bombing role.
The Decision
In 1937, the RLM selected the Junkers Ju 87 as the Luftwaffe's standard dive bomber. This decision was based on several factors:
- Reliability: The Ju 87 demonstrated consistent, predictable performance without catastrophic failures.
- Handling: Pilots found the Ju 87 easier to fly and more forgiving, particularly important for the demanding dive bombing mission.
- Structural integrity: The Ju 87's robust construction inspired confidence, while the He 118's failures raised serious concerns.
- Production considerations: The Ju 87's simpler construction promised easier mass production.
- Dive bombing accuracy: The Ju 87's stability during dives translated to better bombing accuracy.
The He 118 program was cancelled, and the few prototypes built were relegated to testing and experimental duties. The Ju 87 Stuka would go on to become one of World War II's most iconic aircraft, vindicating the RLM's decision.
Technical Specifications (He 118 V1)
- Powerplant: Daimler-Benz DB 600A inverted V-12, 960 hp
- Maximum speed: Approximately 410 km/h (255 mph)
- Range: Approximately 800 km (497 miles)
- Service ceiling: 7,500 m (24,600 ft)
- Bomb load: Up to 500 kg (1,102 lb)
- Defensive armament: One 7.92mm MG 15 machine gun in rear cockpit
- Crew: Two (pilot and gunner/radio operator)
Lessons and Legacy
The He 118's failure offers several important lessons in aircraft development:
Structural Integrity is Paramount
No amount of performance advantage can compensate for fundamental structural weaknesses. The catastrophic in-flight breakup destroyed confidence in the He 118 and demonstrated that dive bombers, which subjected airframes to extreme stresses, required absolutely reliable structures.
Operational Suitability Matters
The Ju 87's success came not from superior performance but from being well-suited to its mission. Its stability, predictability, and ease of maintenance proved more valuable than the He 118's higher speed and more sophisticated design.
Testing Reveals Truth
Comprehensive testing programs exist precisely to reveal problems before aircraft enter service. The He 118's failures during testing, while dramatic and disappointing, prevented far worse disasters that would have occurred had the aircraft entered operational service with unresolved structural issues.
Simplicity Has Value
The Ju 87's relatively simple, robust design proved superior to the He 118's more complex approach. In military aviation, reliability and maintainability often outweigh theoretical performance advantages.
What Might Have Been
It's interesting to speculate how World War II might have differed had the He 118 won the dive bomber competition. Would its structural issues have been resolved? Would its higher speed have provided tactical advantages? Or would its problems have resulted in higher losses and reduced effectiveness?
The reality is that the Ju 87, despite its limitations, proved highly effective in the early war years when the Luftwaffe enjoyed air superiority. The He 118's higher speed would have provided little advantage in these conditions, while its structural and handling issues could have proven catastrophic.
Historical Significance
While the He 118 never achieved operational success, its story remains significant for aviation historians. The aircraft represents the intense competition and rapid development that characterized pre-war German aviation, where multiple manufacturers competed for crucial contracts.
The He 118 also demonstrates that even experienced manufacturers like Heinkel could produce unsuccessful designs. Not every aircraft could be a winner, and the competitive evaluation process, while harsh, ultimately served its purpose of selecting the most suitable aircraft for operational service.
For students of aviation development, the He 118 serves as a cautionary tale about the importance of structural integrity, the value of thorough testing, and the reality that superior performance on paper doesn't always translate to operational success.
Surviving Aircraft and Documentation
No Heinkel He 118 aircraft survive today. The limited number of prototypes built were destroyed during testing or scrapped after the program's cancellation. The He 118 exists now only in photographs, documents, and historical records.
Original technical documentation for the Heinkel He 118 provides valuable insights into late-1930s dive bomber design and the engineering challenges involved in creating aircraft for this demanding role. These documents served as references during the aircraft's brief development period and offer insights into the design philosophy and technical approaches that ultimately proved unsuccessful.
For aviation historians and researchers, authentic He 118 documentation represents primary-source material that illuminates both the aircraft's technical characteristics and the broader context of pre-war dive bomber development. Such materials offer detailed specifications and engineering insights that capture this failed design's place in aviation history and the lessons learned from its shortcomings.
Disclaimer: This item is sold for historical and reference Only. These are either ORIGINAL or COPIES of manuals and blueprints used when these aircraft were in active duty, now transferred into electronic format. These manuals and blueprints are not meant to be used for current update material for certification / repair, but make an excellent reference for the scholar, collector, modeller or aircraft buffs .... For proprietary reasons, we generally only provide civil manuals and blueprints on obsolete Aircraft / Engines / Helicopter. The information is for reference only, and we do not guarantee the completeness, accuracy or currency of any manuals.
Reference herein to any specific commercial products by trade name, trademark, manufacturer, or otherwise, is not meant to imply or suggest any endorsement by, or affiliation with that manufacturer or supplier. All trade names, trademarks and manufacturer names are the property of their respective owners.